Where did all the IP numbers go? The US Department of Defense has them
There have been voices raised that we are running out of IPv4 addresses for some time now. So who has taken them? After discussing this at a coffee break here at Pingdom, we were curious. Are there are any “big spenders” who have allocated a huge share of the IP space for themselves? Yes there are.
When looking at the assigned IP blocks at IANA (Internet Assigned Numbers Authority), what becomes immediately clear is that the US Department of Defense has a significant number of large IP blocks. We only looked at /8 IP blocks, the largest blocks you can get, and there are 12 of them assigned to the US DoD and related organizations. Each /8 block holds 16,777,214 IP addresses, so the DoD have in effect allocated more than 200 million IP addresses. That should hold them for a while.
The closest any other corporation comes to this are Level 3 Communications and Hewlett-Packard, with two /8 blocks each. The DoD-owned IP blocks together with the 26 corporations and universities who have their own /8 blocks hold more than 671 million IP addresses.
These were all early land grabs, most of them made between 1991 and 1995.
Some notables among the companies with one /8 IP block are Apple (but no Microsoft in sight), IBM, Halliburton and the Ford Motor Company.
| Owner | Blocks | ~IP addresses |
|---|---|---|
| US Military (Department of Defense etc.) | 12 | 201 million |
| Level 3 Communications, Inc. | 2 | 33 million |
| Hewlett-Packard | 2 | 33 million |
| AT&T Bell Laboratories (Alcatel-Lucent) | 1 | 16 million |
| AT&T Global Network Services | 1 | 16 million |
| Bell-Northern Research (Nortel Networks) | 1 | 16 million |
| Amateur Radio Digital Communications | 1 | 16 million |
| Apple Computer Inc. | 1 | 16 million |
| Cap Debis CCS (Mercedes-Benz) | 1 | 16 million |
| Computer Sciences Corporation | 1 | 16 million |
| Deparment of Social Security of UK | 1 | 16 million |
| E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co., Inc. | 1 | 16 million |
| Eli Lily and Company | 1 | 16 million |
| Ford Motor Company | 1 | 16 million |
| General Electric Company | 1 | 16 million |
| Halliburton Company | 1 | 16 million |
| IBM | 1 | 16 million |
| Interop Show Network | 1 | 16 million |
| Merck and Co., Inc. | 1 | 16 million |
| MERIT Computer Network | 1 | 16 million |
| Massachusetts Institute of Technology | 1 | 16 million |
| Performance Systems International (Cogent) | 1 | 16 million |
| Prudential Equity Group, LLC | 1 | 16 million |
| Société Internationale De Telecommunications Aeronautiques | 1 | 16 million |
| U.S. Postal Service | 1 | 16 million |
| UK Ministry of Defence | 1 | 16 million |
| Xerox Corporation | 1 | 16 million |
| 40 | 671 million |
The table doesn’t include the blocks allocated for RIRs and other special purposes.
One thing that strikes you is the low number of ISPs on this list. This is most likely due to their late appearance on the internet when it was harder to reserve big IP blocks, forcing them to settle for smaller blocks.
That the US Department of Defense has such a huge amount of the IPv4 address space is partly due to historical reasons: They developed the internet in the first place (ARPANET) and have a strong vested interest in the evolution of the internet.
Of course, IPv6 is on its way which will end this discussion for good (or at least for a looong time), but with a bit of rearranging IPv4 could probably last us for quite a while yet.
A small note:
We only looked at IANA’s own numbers. We didn’t look at the Regional Internet Registries such as ARIN or RIPE, partly to limit the scope of the research and partly because we were only interested in the huge /8 IP blocks. There are only 256 /8 blocks, and many of these are reserved for special purposes.
The New England Patriots held what seemed to be a commanding lead (17-15) with five minutes left of Super Bowl XLVI last night. But the New York Giants came back and managed to win with 21-17.
As Super Bowl 46 is approaching, fans will flock to the Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, Indiana, and to TV sets around the world to follow the New York Giants battle it out with the New England Patriots.
Every Friday we bring you a collection of links to places on the web that we find particularly newsworthy, interesting, entertaining, and topical. We try to focus on some particular area or topic each week, but in general we will cover Internet, web development, networking, performance, and other geeky topics.h
Out of the 
Pingdom’s Mobile Podcast is a weekly show about Internet, web, and mobile stuff. 
Dustin J. Mitchell
February 13th, 2008 at 11:55 am
Surely you’ve seen this comic: http://xkcd.com/195/
I’ve never heard any numbers on actual usage by DOD. I kinda doubt that each Abrams Tank has a publicly-routable IP address
. I wonder if they’re just hanging onto the allocations because they have them and because there isn’t really a shortage of IPv4 addresses.
jbenson2
February 14th, 2008 at 8:04 pm
What is your point? Comparing the entire US Military to Level 3 Communications is a bit ludicrous. I’m surprised the match-up is that close: 12 vs 2.
Royal Pingdom
February 15th, 2008 at 11:05 am
@ jbenson2:
It’s not like we’re comparing them in the way you seem to be suggesting. It’s just an observation. The main point of the article is that the US military has 12 of a very limited number of /8 IP blocks in IPv4, which is a huge share.
propanbutan
February 15th, 2008 at 4:53 pm
jbenson.. the point is that unlike level3, the dod actually has limited use for public ip space. should anyone justify having such a vast range, it would be a communications company and not the military, who are likely to keep their information private for your own sake.
Jeremy
September 20th, 2008 at 7:17 pm
There are 126 Class A networks FYI