Well done to all those bloggers - got to love Boing Boing!!

These were some pretty major improvements. Some of the most basic changes can make all the difference sometimes...

Great compilation of blogs!

it's interesting that most of the successful blogs have something to do with electronic gadgets.

This is one of the best posts for successful blogs I have seen. I have to agree that the images of past and present are very helpful.

Those sites have certainly left a mark on the web

It's great to see that so many blogs are now specializing in consumer electronics and gadgets. I've seen a lot of these blogs before. It's amazing to see how a couple of these sites have just exploded (In a good way :) ) over the last few years.

I share the opinion of a comment further up: The sites degraded their overall layout and I believe the design became worse. At least while quickly scanning through them - and first impressions count, right? - I see more clutter, ads, unclear headings and clues on where to start reading, and most of all white space to rest the eye. Anyway, with RSS most readers might not even realize ;)

Great post! You have compiled them very well, next time also take in ProBlogger and Shoe :p

to me the best actualization is smashing magazine, the worst lifehacker's

Mashable use to take forever to load. Now it loads in mere seconds

@Mikael. Extremely good point!

The title of this blog should be "how 11 successful blogs crammed in more ads above the fold". Nothing inspiring or intriguing here. Yawn ... next!

The fact that there are more ads is not just a "hard balance" for the individual website owners. It speaks to a greater commoditization on the Internet, spurred both by the willingness of advertisers to see the Internet as a new medium, and the insatiable creep of capitalism. Some sites are obviously commercial in their intention (gadget sites, curated and large multi-author sites), but others have merely bought into the idea that money can be made and thus, "why not?". Boing Boing is the most obvious example of a site that started as fringe (doesn't get more fringe than a zine), but is now a successful commercial entity (for no apparent reason beyond some hosting costs).

For some reason, I prefer a lot of the "before" templates. Much cleaner, less cluttered because there were less ads.

Like Taylor Dewey, I generally preferred the first versions. The designs seem to be getting too busy, real "slap in the face" type stuff that I reckon overloads viewers (especially if you are not a regular reader). I think the balance between the boring standard themes that everyday people use and innovative, original design is out of wack.

Nice, one or two I haven't come across before. It is always interesting to visit the Way Back Machine and see how the older styles look so dated.

Everyone has to start somewhere... It's also amazing how much most of the earlier websites looked like basic wordpress themes. As they've improved their styles, it's getting harder and harder to tell they use wordpress underneath (and I'm not saying that they use wordpress, but it sure does look like a lot do).

Great article , very helpful

Very interesting, nice to see how the things change. :) however in most of those cases advertising is more eye-catchy than content

yup, make room for advertising...

instead of writing about these blogs if you write on some good startup blogs then that would be really good. because all people know about all these blogs. any ways good informative post

I think it is interesting to see how widely used banners and 125x125 blocks still are. I would have thought that there would be a better solution as it has been the talk of the town for many years how badly banners convert.

Very interesting article! Intriguing the way the different blogs have developed their layout to better cram in more in less.

Great article. I see that most sites switched to a right hand sidebar. Could the overall volume of sites featuring this style of sidebar begin to "blind" users in the same vein as top level image ads have in the past?

Amazing examples. Thanks for the article.

Thanks everyone for the comments so far! :) Some have remarked on how much advertising there is on the modern versions of the blogs. It's probably a hard balance for them. On one hand they need to make a living and pay their writers and on the other hand it mustn't get too much in the way of the content. Not an easy balancing act.

Funny, I like most of the original versions better. Of course, that is probably because they were advertising-less and thus had more consistent designs. On the other hand, I'm put off by themes that scream "STANDARD BLOG THEME!" I guess that's why people are paid to be designers.

What a coincidence, I visit every one of these sites on a regular basis. Great list, all bloggers should look to these sites for examples of the right way to do it! Great post!

I was just coming to post essentially what Peter did -- are we really seeing design that has evolved for design's sake? Or have the designs simply changed for the sole purpose of accommodating copious amounts of display advertising?

So by successful you mean the content has been successfully buried in a sea of advertising.

I've been reading, commenting and a fan of several of Gawker's blogs over the last few years and have seen the change they've done across the board evolve. While evolution is nice, they've made most of their blogs unreadable in my eyes, unless you use an RSS reader of sorts. Also a fan of Smashing Magazine and was saddened when they changed to their new layout that allows more ads (fine) but reduced the width of their actual content by about 10%. Same is true with a lot of other blogs. Seems in a day and age when even the most weak computers power a monitor that runs at least 1024 pixels wide of screen resolution, bloggers and those who code themes refuse to make the content portion of blogs wider than 500 pixels.

This is a cool list. I love to see how sites evolve (I've been writing about a few such sites on mine) and am encouraged to see that some have made drastic changes in design over the years. Of course, if I'm one of those leaders in the future, you couldn't find a single design that I started with. I've jumped through about a dozen different designs and 4 different content management systems in the last 6 months. One day I'll end up settling, but while the excitement is still here I might as well tweak and play around with as many things as I can.

It's kinda cool how most of them kept the same themes over the years. Branding is very important these days.

Great article, I read a number of these regularly so its interesting to see how they have changed over the years.