Pingdom Home

US + international: +1-212-796-6890

SE + international: +46-21-480-0920

Business hours 3 am-11:30 am EST (Mon-Fri).

Do you know if your website is up right now? We do! LEARN MORE

Google Apps SLA loophole allows for major downtime without consequences

Gmail could be unavailable for more than 21 hours in a day, and Google could still tell you that according to their SLA, the service has had 100% uptime.

It sounds impossible, but it’s a direct consequence of how Google has written its SLA for Google Apps (which includes Gmail, Google Docs, Google Calendar and more). We will explain this in detail further down, but let’s first look at what the SLA actually says.

What the Google Apps SLA says

Here are the key parts, quoted from the Google Apps SLA, emphasis added by us:

“Downtime Period” means, for a domain, a period of ten consecutive minutes of Downtime. Intermittent Downtime for a period of less than ten minutes will not be counted towards any Downtime Periods.

[...]

“Monthly Uptime Percentage” means total number of minutes in a calendar month minus the number of minutes of Downtime suffered from all Downtime Periods in a calendar month, divided by the total number of minutes in a calendar month.

So, “downtime periods” are what’s ultimately used for counting the uptime percentage for Google Apps, and these downtime periods ignore all downtime that lasts less than 10 minutes.

A worst-case scenario

Now back to our initial statement. How does the SLA make it possible to have more than 21 hours of downtime in a day and yet Google would call it 100% uptime?

Here is the problem: What if Google Apps was down for 9 minutes, up for 1 minute, down 9 minutes, etc. That would mean 54 minutes of downtime each hour, but Google still wouldn’t count it because none of the individual downtimes lasted 10 minutes of more.

Over a day (24 hours), that’s 21 hours and 36 minutes of downtime that Google would simply ignore when calculating the final uptime percentage.


Above: Red is downtime, green is uptime. Note that none of the downtime periods above last 10 minutes or more and thus are not counted according to the Google Apps SLA.

It’s an extreme and very unlikely worst-case scenario, but we wanted to illustrate the consequence of how Google’s SLA sums up its downtime and calculates its uptime percentage.

A more likely scenario

Now let’s take a much more likely example of intermittent problems:

3m, 8m, 12m, 5m, 9m, 14m, 4m = 57 minutes of actual downtime

But Google would only count this as 26 minutes of downtime, including only the downtime periods lasting 12 and 14 minutes.


Above: In this scenario, only the downtime periods lasting 12 and 14 minutes (marked with yellow) would be counted according to the Google Apps SLA.

Short outages are common in the real world

The problem with the Google Apps SLA is that short outages, less than 10 minutes in length, are actually very common in the real world.

As you may know, we here at Pingdom run an uptime monitoring service, and we know from our own experience (and a LOT of data from thousands of sites) that it’s much more common for sites to have multiple short intervals of downtime instead of a few long ones.

The 99.9% monthly uptime guarantee in the Google Apps SLA allows for 43 minutes of downtime in a 30-day month, but ignoring problems that last less than 10 minutes at a time will definitely make it much easier for Google to honor its SLA.



1 comments
Jason
Jason

Actually it is even more interesting, if they monitor by the second, which I'm sure they do. 9 Mins and 59 seconds would not count as downtime, so you can have 9:59 mins down and 1 second up, which would give you basically about 2 minutes of uptime daily.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] claim they had 100% uptime. That’s the gist of an analysis penned by Pingdom, who took a closer look at the Service Level Agreement for Google [...]

  2. [...] may be down for ages but it will always deny the fact and claim to have a 100% uptime. Royal Pingdom comes out with some detailed analysis, with a study of Google SLA. Downtime for Google is only [...]

  3. [...] Google Appsはどれも1日21時間ダウンする可能性があるのに、グーグルは100%のアップタイムを謳うことができる。―これがGoogle Appsのサービス レベル契約(SLA:日本語版)を虫眼鏡で眺め回したPingdomがまとめた分析の主旨である。 [...]

  4. [...] document designed to protect the site (not the retailer) in case of any problem.Pingdom has crafted a wonderful example, based on the Google SLA given to its cloud customers. Google’s SLA: “Downtime Period” means, for a domain, a period of ten consecutive [...]

  5. [...] Google auch im Business-Umfeld immer populärer wird, ist mir ein Artikel ins Auge gesprungen, welcher das SLA von Google Mail, Google Apps, etc. untersucht hat. Dabei wurde [...]

  6. [...] Pingdom ha fatto un’analisi approfondita della cosa. Furbo da parte di Google, no? Così è possibile garantire il promesso 99.9% di uptime senza alcuno sforzo. Questo articolo è stato pubblicato Martedì, 9 Dicembre 2008 alle ore 09:08 Se non vuoi perdere nemmeno un articolo del mio blog abbonati al feed RSS. Se non sai cos’è un feed RSS puoi guardare questo video, spiega tutto! [...]

  7. [...] Apps SLA loophole allows for major downtime without consequences reports Pingdom a leading internet uptime [...]

  8. [...] Apps SLA loophole allows for major downtime without consequences reports Pingdom a leading internet uptime [...]

  9. [...] Pingdom: Google Apps SLA loophole allows for major downtime without consequences [...]

  10. [...] Y vete tú a reclamar a Google, que tiene bien redactadito su acuerdo de nivel de servicios (SLA) permitiéndole estar no disponible más de 21 horas en un día… Para mí, Google será la mejor opción cuando me firme un [...]

  11. [...] downtime – Perhaps the most prominent example of this is Google Apps (including Gmail) which won’t count any downtime that is shorter than 10 minutes. So if Gmail were to be down five different nine-minute periods, you’d have had 45 minutes of [...]